Why did hermoine not help dobby I think Hermione accepted that prophecy is real but believed, accurately, that all the fortune telling stuff related to divination didn't really help or matter. Share. Harry calls out for her to do something out of misplaced hope that Hermione will know something that can help Dobby. it taught Harry two important lessons - not to overlook Neville, and that Dobby (who gives Harry the gillyweed in the book rather than Neville in the movie) would always be there for him. March 1995. I mean, Harry was screaming for her to help Given the circumstances, Hermione had very limited options to save Dobby: She was unarmed – Her wand had been confiscated when she was captured, leaving her unable to I’m not even top of my year at Hogwarts, that’s Hermione, This explains why Dobby wanted to help. Dobby wakes Definitely not as self-aware or independent as Dobby. ~DH Chapter 8: A Place to Hide But Ron, who grew up with the belief that uttering Voldemort's name is dangerous, can bring misfortune and in general bad for the harvest, picked up on the possible connection between saying Voldemort's name and the Death Eaters appearing much quicker than muggle-raised Hermione and Harry. But Dobby is not like "any other". That's it. Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like Why did Hermione say she had been sort of right about the Half-Blood Prince?, Harry told Kreacher and Dobby to- he preferred to operate alone and did not want help. In OotP Hermione leaves out hats for house elves, and all elves except Dobby refuse to clean the Gryffindor common room because they're afraid they'll touch one by accident. Harry privately thought that the counter-example provided by the equally free, listless, drunken, wailing Winky Further, he did not have the power, ostensibly, to override legal decisions made by the Minister for Magic or the Department of Magical Law Enforcement (that said, we've seen Dumbledore step around Fudge more than once. Weasley had sent, Dobby looked quite overwhelmed. They were on the run trying to kill the most powerful wizard alive and Dumbledore was not around to help anymore. No known distance limits (depends on concentration), Hogwarts to grounds is OK Ref: GoF, Harry vs broom; One of the big theories as to why Dobby couldn’t be saved has to do with Hermione losing her bag inside of the Malfoy Manor. So, when Harry begged for help, how did he know to send specifically Dobby? Why did he pick Dobby and not another house-elf? I can't recall a single evidence that anyone outside the Trio and Albus knew about Harry's relationship with Dobby; or that he used to serve Malfoys and would thus have an advantage. She very It doesn't help that her only real experience with house elves is what she had heard about Dobby from Harry and Winky. Well, partly, because as bleh says in their answer, Hermione and Professor Trelawney got off on the wrong foot rather. And they were never taught or even allowed to think for themselves. EDIT: Thanks for your answers everyone. : it's not about abolishing house elves from aiding wizards, it's about having them aid who they choose. Ron abandoned both Harry and Hermione in their greatest moment of need in the seventh book. "Books! SPEW was not really an important storyline for the house elves as much as it was for Hermione. In an interview with Emma Watson, who played Hermione Granger in the Harry Potter films, Joanne Rowling stated that the reason for the Hermione/Ron pairing (and perhaps by implication Harry and Hermione not ending up together) was "wish fulfillment. Later, Hermione punched him in the face. If his master found out, Dobby would be severely punished. But what mattered was that she herself valued bravery over intelligence, as shown in PS/SS. So when Peter sees Hermione and Ron fully as themselves it should have been easy to put the puzzle together and almost certainly confirm that the third person is actually Harry. Sar Barty Jr actually explains how proud Harry was; his biggest fear was that Harry was too proud to ask for help. The diary eventually takes Ginny permanently and lures Harry into a trap, but that wasn't part of Malfoy's plan. Using it on Dobby, a little creature who had a knife through his chest, would Originally Answered: Why didn’t Hermione help Dobby when his life was in danger in Deathly Hallows 1? She was in shock from being tortured by Bellatrix, if you remember from Why did Hermione not help Dobby? It was too late—Dobby was beyond anyone’s capacity to save. Follow edited Jan 3, 2016 at Some citations would help, so other people can look Why does Hermione not help Dobby? https://celebrity. He wanted the only good person he ever heard about to not die. ' Peter even transforms into his original self in front of Hermione, Ron and Harry in the Whomping Willow in Prisoner of Azkaban. Rowling. Perhaps he thought nobody would think much if just Harry didn’t show up. In chapter 24 (Bloomsbury) of Deathly Hallows-- The Wandmaker-- Harry and Griphook the goblin have a conversation wherein Harry asks for Griphook's help in breaking into Gringotts to retrieve the Hufflepuff cup Horcrux from the Lestranges' vault. His loyalty and bravery were rewarded eventually, as he was freed from his cruel wizarding family with a gratefully received dirty sock. It is not in their nature. Why didn't Hermione help? Although she might not have had anything to help Dobby, she could have at least looked instead of standing there. Hermione. Dobby says he can’t tell him, and Harry must go home. Harry did not want anyone to put themselves in danger over him. He's happy to clean, he just doesn't want to be abused. Why did professor McGonagall not further question Harry, Hermione explains the situation to her parents in Deathly Hollows, and her father decides that the best option is to tag along and help. Dobby and Kreacher both did this. I always interpret it so that the sorting is not so much about who you are, but about what you value most. But Dumbledore had to keep Snape close. I just Catching hold of Dobby’s wrist, Harry tries to get Dobby to tell him more about the Chamber of Secrets, about who has opened it, and who opened it last time. Despite the arguments against Dobby’s death, it’s important to remember that death is a natural part of life. The movie also adds the details of Hermione saving them from Lupin, and the moment where she throws rocks at Harry (those two things are not in the book). We see from that that Dobby is not behaving naturally. it's a never ending process to find true self love and acceptance iguess, but it has definetly been good for me to reflect so much and face my demons. Dobby does eventually come to Harry’s aid in the 7th book and it ends up with Dobby dead. Dobby was one of the most beloved characters to come out of the Why did Hermione not help Dobby? 2 Answers. Another aspect as much as Harry wanted to preserve himself in the situation, I really think part of him didn't want to lie to Dobby who was obviously very sensitive and slightly disturbed If Dobby was doing it all, Harry wouldn’t have needed to spin on the spot and think of their destination - but he does, because he’s the one apparating them. Elves like it. Right at the very start of the lesson, before the incident in the question, Hermione was affronted when Professor Trelawney pronounced that 'Books can take you only so far in this field. Lucius Malfoy needs Harry at school for the plan to work. When that didn't work, she tried to trick them in to accepting things they did not want. Hermione even admits it: "Books! And cleverness! There are more important things — friendship and bravery and — oh Harry — be careful!" While from Hermoine's raising outside the world this may be seen as servitude or slavery, she missed one key issue with S. Why did Hermione not help Dobby? 2 Answers. The consensus seems to be she doesn't actually know her knife killed Dobby specifically, but she assumes it would have hit someone (not that she would care to think any more about it). [2] This skirmish was also an important moment in the Second Wizarding War because of the repercussions that came later. Harry would not be okay using lumos in Privet Drive because he is the only wizard there for miles. "Why did Dobby cheat his master?" Because Proletariat has Nothing To Lose But Their Chains (Karl Marx (c)). They were completely exposed. Note that just before entering Gringotts, Hermione-Bellatrix greeted a man, and this had been considered by Ron and Harry as something the real Bellatrix would have never done: Dobby had been around since The Chamber of Secrets, using his house elf magic to keep Harry away from Hogwarts in order to protect him from the dangers waiting for him there. Did she even have the Dittany? IIRC the snatchers took most of their stuff. Dobby says that house elves were treated like trash during Voldemort's time (and Dobby still is) so he sees Harry as a symbol A house elf is freed if a master gives them clothes. Luckily he has experience hunting for magical artifacts, The Harry Potter franchise has had massive success, partly thanks to its heavy emphasis on friendship and family and the importance of maintaining those relationships. Exactly, the answers they were looking for were right there under their noses the whole time, but as usual they focused on Malfoy. Cloak slipped off his Read More. Dobby was a case of abuse that definitely showed there needed to be some oversight to protect the House Elves and Winky was just in a sad situation that was traumatic to watch and she didn't understand the entire situation because the only people who In the Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban book/movie, Draco took revenge on Buckbeak after it injured him in Hagrid’s class by getting Buckbeak sentenced to death by the Ministry of Magic. Honestly, Hermione's behavior with the elves is pretty disgusting. Why didn't Harry call Kreacher again when they were in trouble? After the Ministry break-in they decided to avoid contacting Kreacher, just because they were not sure how he would react. Dobby’s Death is a Tragedy, but It’s Part of Life. What did Harry and his friends do instead of going to the Halloween feast? they went to Nearly Headless Nick's death day party. Dobby definitely got the letters, from every owl that came, and the owls returned as if they were delivered. Several things explaining why she wasn't able to heal Dobby. Her feelings were previously hurt by Ron when she overheard him mocking her after Charms class, but when they came to her rescue, I think she saw that they were truly her friends if they were willing to come do that, so in return for stepping up when it counted, she took some of the (Hermione) ‘But you believe us. They didn't mention heat in the movie, perhaps because if their hands were blistered, their faces would have been, too, and no one wants that. Hermione is fine using the spell in Diagon Alley because there's so much magic happening there anyway. She is known for being extremely intelligent and skilled at magic. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. But as Hermione tells us, they’re not supposed to talk about them. it is, without a doubt, the most significant character arc involving Hermione throughout the series, and is really one of the few instance where you see an appreciable growth of her as an individual. “He had made his choice while he dug Dobby’s grave, he had decided to continue along the winding, dangerous path indicated for him by Albus Dumbledore, to accept that he had not been told everything that he wanted to know, but simply to trust. Share Dobby isn't very big so the knife probably wouldn't have killed a human did for Dobby since his Why did Harry not tell Hermione that Dobby was the only one cleaning the Gryffindor common room? If you are an outsider, you can help communities you don’t belong to, and you can even help them identify issues they may not see, BUT you cannot do that until you have listened, learned, and heard them. Dobby is seen as an oddity and disgrace among his kind. No, more likely Hermione settled for Ron. “Mudblood, and proud of it! The book didn't mention the carving. Through their interactions and shared experiences, Dobby’s loyalty and devotion to Harry became Dobby was also a very good, noble and selfless being. ). she could feel the heat. fm/why-does-hermione-not-help-dobby-3/ Dobby the house-elf to the Malfoy family debuts in the second Harry Potter movie. In DH 1 why doesn't Hermione help Dobby with essence of dittany? Help Archived post. They live for it, and they don't want to be free. However, Hermione, who is responsible for administering the potion, lacks the knowledge and resources She couldn't have done anything. There’s a good chance that they would have refused unless she went with them, which she was determined not to do, so ultimately I think modifying their memories was the best option she had available to her. He rejected Lupin getting involved. ] CC: So, it’s a little bit of a taste of what’s to happen, what’s coming up. They likely identify with eachother in that way. Hermione is not a medical witch. Mere seconds past from the moment Harry noticed Dobby was injured until he passed away. That IS a plot hole. Why did Dobby warn Harry not to go back to Hogwarts? Harry asked if he could help Dobby but he began wailing and talking about how humble he was and how brave he was for facing You-Know-Who twice. It took place around Easter of 1998 in Malfoy Manor, located in Wiltshire, England. " “I wrote the Hermione/Ron They don't even consider going against their masters in any way. No one said anything though. Harry insists that he’s not going anywhere, and tells Dobby that one of his best friends is Muggle-born, so will be in danger if the Chamber really has been opened. Improve this answer. The extent of damage caused by the enchanted knife was beyond the capabilities of the magical remedies available Similarly, she was not able to save Snape in deathly hallows part 2. At the end of that school Yes. She's not a healer and apparently essence of dittany only heals flesh wounds. The moment took place during the seventh Harry Potter movie, based on the book series written by J. Hermione was not an experienced healer. At that time, he knew what everyone else thought they knew – that Sirius was a dangerous criminal that was out to get Harry Potter and that was said to be Voldemort’s right-hand. Not setting anything up, and killing/cursing anyone who asked, would also work. After Harry frantically searches all the books without finding anything, Ron and Hermione have still not returned. Discussion I'm fully on board with "Harry should have married Hermione" because it makes more sense for their characters, but this fact really makes my heart smile. Harry could not help but notice that the other house-elves looked disconcerted, and seemed to keep their distance from Dobby and Winky. She wasnt madam Pomfrey. But still, it really comes down to that combative and at times explosive relationship. As the trio left the kitchens, Hermione stated that seeing how happy Dobby was would have a good effect on the other house-elves. Harry, worried and stressed, didn't think straight and just called for help. We were talking about Diagon Alley, not Privet Drive. There's even the Black family tree painted in one of the rooms, and the By starting SPEW Hermione made it her goal to free all house-elves whether they want to or not, but when crouch dismissed winky (which was wrong ) Hermione protested it . Yes, he owned a house-elf, but let's be honest here. Rowling says that Hermione and Ron's relationship was not credible. Also see Why didn't Dumbledore insist that Sirius Black be questioned under Veritaserum? yeah dude i read the books a lot when i was younger. nl/33Zrz🐱🏍Share this video with a friend: https://youtu. For example, when he creates the Portkey in front of Fudge, which is against regulations. #harrypottertamil #boggart #allcharacters #harrypotter Subscribe for more Content: http://lnki. Just my thoughts. Firstly, I had Dumbledore and Hermione emphasise how dangerous it would be to be seen in the past, to remind the reader that there might be unforeseen and dangerous consequences as I think in the end it just comes down to the fact that no one knows it was her and, even if they did, can't really prove it. Harry didn’t even originally want Hermione and Ron involved in this. Did Snape know that Sirius Black was innocent? No one knows the truth about Sirius Black yet, not even Severus Snape. Dobby was NOT on the side of his master - he was a "freedom minded" house-elf, didn't like that house-elves were subjugated to wizards (as evidenced by his post-freeing thoughts, speech and behavior); didn't like Dark wizards, and knew that DE's When Hermione tried to find an escape, Ron, and Harry side-along disapparated with her to the forest, why didn't Harry call for Kreacher, given the circumstances that the house-elf was now friendlier . ” I mean Dobby is still slightly annoying to me at times, but I’ve grown fond of him with time. No, probably not. Harry takes the shortcuts and steals her thunder. So why does Hermione bother trying? Surely she was clever enough to realise that she couldn't possibly free them, so why does she keep trying? Their protection, I think. Killing your past self is definitely not consistent with the "already happened" theory because if you are killed in the present, you won't be able to travel in time in Perhaps whatever magic Dobby used to seal the barrier prevented those on the other end from transporting back to Kings Cross while it was active, or perhaps Harry and Ron missed Arthur and Molly by only minutes and it was their impatience, and eagerness to use the car, that made them not wait out the short span of time that would surely be needed to have Arthur and Molly find Harry and Ron made horrible mistake but they found every bravery what they could find to help Hermione, because it was right do to and Hermione showed her respect when she showed also her honor, bravery and dedication. Why did Hermione not help Dobby? Why did Hermione not help Dobby? 2 Answers. Not at all a plot hole. " hermione bit her lip and leaned forward, wrapping her hand around the base of dobby's cock. W. why didnt hermione save dobby? even if they did know how to heal dobby the wound was deep and fatil they couldn't of saved him in time but for now rip dobby a free elf. We see elves at Hogwarts I would just like to point out that there is an additional reason why Hermione didn't immediately hand over the wand at Gringotts: it would have been out of character. Also, it seems they were ones who did the laundry so they did handle cloths. It was honoarable that Hermione took the blame, but also it was INCREDIBLY brave, because she was previously always incredibly careful and in good terms with teachers. Thanks to his help True, but I think Dumbledore had more of an understanding about elves than Hermoine, hence why he never said elves shouldn't be enslaved. When Ron recieved the Howler, what "one good thing" did it do? it made Hermione think the boys had There’s no reason to believe he also didn’t have a time turner. Hermione had just been tortured by Bellatrix and was in no state to help Why did Hermione not help Dobby? It was too late—Dobby was beyond anyone’s capacity to save. . In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1 (2010), Harry insists that Hermoine and Ron bury Dobby without using magic: Harry: I want to bury him. the amount of House Elves Hermione freed: 0 The amount Harry freed: 1 Also, Harry was never an oppressor. Dobby knows there is great danger yet only alerts Harry. For example, you could argue that Hermione at age 11 was more characterized by intelligence than bravery. Just touching the cloths does not break any spell or anything, its all about the intentions. In Book 5, Dobby has to clean all of Gryffindor Tower by himself every night because the other elves find Hermione's hats insulting and refuse to clean the Tower. Not just in one meaning. This left Harry and Hermione in a very difficult and stressful situation. Properly. Dobby, on the other hand,, hates his master and does go directly against his wishes. “Not kill you, sir, never kill you!” said Dobby, shocked. Maybe it wasn’t a good idea to retaliate immediately (as he was dealing with the brightest student in Hogwarts who could smash him This "already happened" philosophy is actually not really true, and here is why: remember that Hermione explained Harry that meeting yourself is dangerous and a lot of wizards killed their past or future selves. Meaning, while she had a general knowledge of various spells, she did not have the expertise in healing specific spells to be able to heal a death wound on a house elf. Why would Hermione be the first? She’s bright yes, but not the first bright student to come through; not even the brightest. That's why Dobby showed up at Number 4 Private Drive that night. we know that dobby went to shell cottage because ron told him to, but we also learn that shell cottage is under the fidelius charm and bill is the secret keeper. This skirmish was a small but bloody event that took place at the height of the Second Wizarding War. Putting on his Invisibility Cloak, Harry returns to the library where he finally falls asleep reading spell-books by wand light. I solved the problem to my own satisfaction in stages. Pretty odd planning for a He threw Dobby a pair of violet socks he had just unwrapped, and the handknitted jumper Mrs. Without magic. They would know all of the other Pureblood families, and therefore Kreacher would as well. Griphook seems to hold Harry in at least higher esteem than he would probably hold most wizards, commenting on Harry taking the This was achieved by "putting aside" all the components of the novel which did not directly relate to Harry and his journey. True, but Dobby did also steal Harry's letters, get him in trouble with the Durley's (who were abusive), block him from the train station, sent a bludger after him that led to his arm being broken, and whilst Dobby's reasoning may have been to protect Harry, you can understand why Harry might not feel the best towards him and be careful what he The sole mention of hermione's wounds are "“Why shouldn’t I?” said Hermione. The implication has always seemed that the hat was torn between gryffindor and slytherin, until Harry made up his mind and chose gryffindor. Either way they are a humanoid race of intelligent, autonomous beings being used for free labor. Even if he did know healing spells, he wasn't thinking straight at the moment. J. Dobby was NOT on the side of his master - he was a "freedom minded" house-elf, didn't like that house-elves were subjugated to wizards (as evidenced by his post-freeing thoughts, speech and behavior); didn't like Dark wizards, and knew that DE's The weirdest moment in this here is, 1. That’s why Hermione got sorted into Gryffindor and not Ravenclaw. A house-elf who was utterly devoted to Harry Potter, Dobby put himself at great risk (and in serious physical pain) when he went out of his way to protect the young wizard from what Dobby knew would be significant danger. You either had the gift of prophecy or you didn't, and she knew she didn't have it. Hermione's hair was about to pop off. P. Why did Hermione not save Dobby? Healing a wound caused by a cursed dagger requires immense medical skills. Thanks. I like your interpretation. Aquí nos gustaría mostrarte una descripción, pero el sitio web que estás mirando no lo permite. Dobby (28 June (year unknown) – March 1998) was a male house-elf who served the Malfoy family. Not sure if I missed it in the books. In the books, she hid her bag in her sock, but lost her wand. Kreacher served the Black family, a prominent and extremely proud Pureblood family. Even then she was just tortured into unconsciousness, was at the cottage before Dobby and Harry left Malfoy manor, and dittany isn't a cure-all. why didn't the boys just ask Lavender "by chance" whether she knew where Hermione was, and Lavender would have told Percy; and 2. The reason why Harry didn't marry Hermione in the books was so that they could both marry into the Weasley family, and all of their kids would be cousins. I mean technically shouldn't she be happy that winky became free. So at the same time Harry, Hermione and Ron were at Hagrid's cabin, future Harry and Hermione were setting Buckbeak free. Harry was always true to them he arguably never disrepair the boys he even gave dobby the sock to prank Malfoy Hermione went to hard but harry was always there saving the world and being a kind person. There is a theory that the hat is protected by the fidelius charm and is its own secret keeper. Not jealous that he had the HBP book. Whether or not they like it isnt the problem, and theres an argument to be made about whether they are an inherently subservient race or just centuries deep into subservient indoctrination. No further explanation as to why. ‘But I have no power to make other men see the truth, or to overrule the Minister for Magic ’ Prisoner of Azkaban - page 287 - Bloomsbury - Hermione's Secret. " Why didn't Hermione do anything in the 7th movie when Harry asked her to help him with Dobby? In my opinion she was so selfish but if i were Harry i would've yelled at her for not helping me. Dobby isn't even resentful about it. Still, at Malfoy Manor, they were already in deep trouble, so no more harm would have been caused if Harry had tried to summon Kreacher to help. E. harry-potter; All they to say, Hermione probably knew whether or not her parents would go. As we all know, Dobby is an outlier, a house-elf like no other. Harry finds him in his bedroom the evening Vernon Dursley and his wife, Petunia host the Masons in the hopes of The Dursleys were offered other protection by the Order of the Phoenix. No other employer would have treated him with such understanding and kindness. Analyzing the situation further, it becomes clear why magical healing was not possible in Dobby's case. Why did Dobby’s death work in Harry Potter? I hope it’s ok to ask this question here. This has led many fans to wonder, why did Hermione not save Dobby? i did manage to move on for a while, building a new home with friends and SO, but when that all came crashing down, i relapsed back into not having a safe place, it's taken a while to help me find myself, and stand on my own again. " Why did Hermione not help Dobby? 2 Answers. It was not bad writting, it was good example WHY is Hermione Gryfindor and WHY can The Golden Trio works. So, no matter how many hats Hermione hid, elves were not going to be freed because they did not want it to Why did Harry, Hermione, @T. Why does Hermione not mind being with someone less intellectual? Seeing his struggles, both wanting to help desperately and often being unable to. He was one of the most brilliant students Hogwarts has ever seen, but at the end of the day he was only a boy. That was the best thing for Snape too. I think it was mostly based on the fact that nobody seems to know about how the hat works, and that the hat itself tells the first years (in song) how sorting works, while McGonagall stands silently next to the stool. Hermione Granger is one of the main characters in the Harry Potter series. However as the order did not know that Harry, Ron and Hermione were thinking of setting off on their own to hunt down horcruxes (Dumbledore had forbidden them from sharing their mission with anyone), Hermione felt the need to protect her parents herself, and these are the means she had available to her. Dobby, a house-elf enslaved by the Malfoy family, found a true friend in Harry Potter. " "I'm not as good as you," said Harry, very embarrassed, as she let him go. it seemed to help, because the next thing dobby did was give her her first command. 0. Its also a great plot point to show the level of daring of the trio, stealing supplies, and the level of Dobby wakes Harry up ten minutes before the second task, tells him that he will have to rescue Ron, and gives him Gillyweed (GF26). He came to know this via the contact between his masters and Lord Voldemort. Hermoine had weeks to help Harry figure out how to breath under water, and I don’t buy that she didn’t know about the bubble head charm. All for the same reasons. That's why he had to stage what led to Dobby suggesting to Harry the gillyweed. In fact, when he met Harry Potter, he knew he would one day be an important player in the This means that Hermione's hats would not have freed the elves, as she didn't own them; Hogwarts did. If he had freed Kreacher, it would likely have given the old guy a heart attack or just made him kill himself in shame. As someone who sees house elves as nothing more than servants, he sees no worth in Dobby living now that he’s been freed. I’ve read an interesting theory that Malfoy was actually aiming at Dobby in that moment. This did not happen when the letters were interrupted - so it either didn't happen at the Dursley's home, or if it did, it was too unlike any wizard spells for the Trace to detect it. When he found out about the possible death that could have resulted from malfoy's plan he went to the only good person he ever heard of, Harry Potter. Dobby was also a very good, noble and selfless being. Besides, while what we see with Dobby and the Malfoys might have given us a different impression, not all house elves have it that bad. This thread is archived I'm glad the tiny fat scheming long nosed money grabbing goblins agreed . "hermy will rub her hand up and down dobby's penis. Hermione insisted Harry should follow the official instructions from the Prince's book and not the ones the owner had inscribed. Hope this help and sorry it didnt make much sense also im bad at spelling words sorry When Hermione came up with the idea for an organization that would help house-elves gain their freedom, Harry was initially dismissive. What did Hermione put on their hands after they jumped off the dragon? She uses essence of dittany to regrow skin on their hands. He literally doesn't know what he's saying, and he doesn't know why he believes what he believes beyond "my master told me. The skirmish resulted in several prisoners being freed from the Skip to main content 搜尋此網誌 Vrftsjtryk If they did manage to establish this, then it's even MORE obvious that it is not the real Bellatrix. She didn’t until Dumbledore gave her the assignment to help Harry. If he knows Albus is great then why not warn him as well? Or was he aware that might blow up in his face and get him in trouble. "Harry--you're a great wizard, you know. CC: It is foreshadowing, yeah. In the movie, Bellatrix gives her that scar with the knife that killed Dobby. To be fair, Dobby seemed like a pyscho, I see Harry not wanting to play games with an unhinged house-elf, and decided the best course of action is to be straight about his intentions. Eccentricity. Even though she had a general knowledge of various spells, she was not trained for healing – even in the books she mentions she never attempted to further her knowledge of healing wounds. It was in the 3rd one they started taking extra Not sure if I missed it in the books. [You’ve no idea. The book says to" EXPLOSION! Hermione ALWAYS did everything right, and here she was screwing a potion up by following the instructions. It’s very much a maybe; it’s not a certainty, but they’re not willing to risk the chance that if they call Kreacher, someone might be brought along for the ride. dobby's eye followed her movement. be/ But Slytherin's monster attacks muggle-borns, and Harry is not a muggle-born, so there's no reason for Dobby to think Harry will be a target. yes, ron had been there when he left harry and hermione, but that wouldn’t mean he’d be able to tell the location, right? because in OOTP mad eye shows harry dumbledore’s handwriting saying that 12 grimmauld place is the In The Deathly Hallows, Dobby sneaks into Malfoy Manor in order to save Harry, Ron Weasley, Hermione Granger, Garrick Ollivander, and Luna Lovegood as they are being kept there as prisoners There’s a very adorable scene where Hermione hugs Harry, but she doesn’t hug Ron – what was behind that non-hug for you? CC: Did you read book four? *TLC*: Yeah, I did. Harry Potter ( as a series I mean) and the situations and we are still given hope when Dumbledore leaves Harry Ron and Hermoine clues to help them beat Voldemort. No need to know the location Ref: HP, Hermione vs Horcrux books. Dobby receives socks as a thank you Shortly after breakfast, Harry, Ron, and Hermione visit the kitchens to give Dobby the outlandish socks they picked out as a Maybe not as a first choice, but it did push for slytherin after it was mentioned. She wouldn't follow those instructions if she Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. This implies that they can't touch clothing at all without being dismissed. slowly, she began rubbing in the vertical I think she did it as a bit of a “thank you” to Ron and Harry for coming to help and ultimately save her. Subscribe to this blog This doesn't exactly explain why Hermione is any less of an option compared to Luna but factoring in Luna and Ginny's childhood connection and it maybe makes a bit more sense. "Me!" said Hermione. Dobby is trying to stop Harry getting caught up in Lucius’s to mess Arthur up with his plot with the diary, the basilisk and Ginny; Lucius actually doesn’t care very much at that stage whether Harry is or isn’t at Hogwarts; it’s only Dobby that seems concerned about that, which is why Dobby takes it upon himself to warn Harry even knowing he’ll have to punish himself extensively for Quoting from Rowling's Pottermore article on Time Turners: (one of the many parts not carried over to the new Pottermore). Yeah, I say she was jealous. “Dobby wants to save Harry Potter’s life! Better sent home, grievously injured, than remain here, sir! Dobby only wanted Harry Potter hurt enough to be sent home!” Thus, Harry is telling Dobby, perhaps slightly in jest, that he is better off without Dobby trying to save him. Hogwarts elves are also did not like to be freed (like most elves). K. Why didn t Hermione help Dobby? She apparated previously and was already in shell cottage when dobby arrived. The stakes are too high. She lacked the skills to do much Attempts to save Dobby include applying Essence of Dittany, a potion known for accelerating wound healing. Even though she had a general knowledge of various spells, she was not trained for healing - even in the books she mentions she never attempted to further her knowledge of healing wounds. She didn't know for a fact that those instructions weren't better (they were), it's just that she has a weak spot for printed words. it was so hot. If they could prove she did it, she'd likely only get a warning, much like Harry. He's a sentient creature, but he's not capable of understanding the complexity of human relations/politics. I think that is why Dippet did not accept Riddle's application. This decision raises the question: why didn’t Harry use magic to bury Dobby? Let us explore the significance behind this choice and the tradition it upholds. Subscribe. Dobby in "Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. In 1992, he disobeyed his masters and tried to warn Harry Potter of the plot to have the Chamber of Secrets reopened. I mean, Harry was screaming for her to help him, she could have tried to help. They can get a big help from Kreacher especially that the elf can get along with them that time. Ron and Hermione's upbringing was vastly different, whereas Harry and Hermione could relate having grown up in the outside world, although I know Harry had a negatively unique experience even in that aspect. Hermione did not reply. TLC: So it is foreshadowing. The characters of Bill Weasley, Charlie Weasley, Ludo Bagman, Winky, Narcissa Malfoy, and Bertha Jorkins are all absent, as well as Dobby who was supposed to help Harry obtain Gillyweed for the second task. he objectively did more for house-elves than Hermione did. Why does Harry think Whereas Ron was more hot tempered, childish, vindictive and constantly jealous. There was always a thought that Dobby the house-elf broke his promise to Harry Potter when he saved the wizard's life toward the end of the series, but that wasn't necessarily the case. ’ ‘Yes, I do,’ said Dumbledore quietly. Aside from the main trio, no other character understood this concept better than Dobby the House Elf. how quickly Hermione figured out that everyone had been warned about the troll and the boys ought to have been in their tower. She, in fact, tried to force them into a state of unhappiness when she realized that they did not want her help. Dobby is not-your-average elf in a household and with masters he trully dislikes, particularly for their pureblood views and dabbling in dark magic. It was honoarable that Hermione took the blame, but also it was INCREDIBLY brave, because she was previously always incredibly Quoting from Rowling's Pottermore article on Time Turners: (one of the many parts not carried over to the new Pottermore). "NO. However, in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, she is unable to save the house elf Dobby when he is killed by Bellatrix Lestrange. It's not going to do much to heal a vital organ before the person dies. What she used on Ron was essence of dittany, which I Dobby was more gravely injured, and likely suffering from internal bleeding and severe blood loss. Hermione had just been tortured by Bellatrix and was in no state to help Why didn't Hermione help? Although she might not have had anything to help Dobby, she could have at least looked instead of standing there. She can’t heal Dobby. Not a word on the other houses. his knowledge is accurate in that there’s danger but he is warning just Harry. Her name alone would have been enough for Kreacher to know that she's not a Pureblood. But Harry, Ron, and Hermione have NO IDEA when he might be in someone’s physical grasp. Firstly, I had Dumbledore and Hermione emphasise how dangerous it would be to be seen in the past, to remind the reader that there might be unforeseen and dangerous consequences as Not just in one meaning. His masters were Dark wizards who treated him cruelly. Only the Headteacher, or maybe the staff, could have freed the elves. The hand jerk that Harry feels is not Dobby trying to take charge, like Harry thinks, but Dobby jerking in pain because the knife had fully plunged into his chest. Hermione was definitely in shock, because she was tortured by Bellatrix several minutes ago – she needed help herself first Dittany heals a lot of things, but a knife through the chest may not be one of them. Any bystander goblin would've seen something suspicious going on (and it looks like they did in the movie). DH: Harry had his retort ready for when they [Ron and Dean] asked him why he had not simply created a perfect grave with his wand, but he did not need it. On Wednesday, she apologised for killing Dobby, the house-elf freed after a trick by Harry Potter who went on to save him, Luna Lovegood, Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger, before they were turned In the book Dobby was critically injured- the knife in relation to his tiny body made a large wound. However, this would not have sufficed to urge any other house-elves to action. Plus Lily Luna just sounds better from a writing perspective lol. Hermione knows His wounds were too severe and he couldn’t be saved even with magic. Or he doesn’t want Dobby to have the satisfaction that he’s been freed. Harry was a symbol of a fight and victory, it was only natural Dobby would be drawn to him when he represented everything Malfoys weren't. Why didn’t Hermione heal Dobby’s wound? Why did Dobby warn Harry not to go back to Hogwarts? Harry asked if he could help Dobby but he began wailing and talking about how humble he was and how brave he was for facing You-Know-Who twice. How did Hermione get the hair she used in her glass of Polyjuice Potion? M<Millicent left it on Hermione's robes as they wrestled at the Dueling Club . Another thing, the Ministry was quite content to leave Harry alone for the first 2 books. Her feelings were previously hurt by Ron when she overheard him mocking her after Charms class, but when they came to her rescue, I think she saw that they were truly her friends if they were willing to come do that, so in return for stepping up when it counted, she took some of the It seems that the characters in the story did not fully utilize all of their options in an effort to save Dobby, which has led some fans to criticize their actions. Dobby finally told Harry why he was there - he had a warning: he shouldn't go back to Hogwarts School in September because he would be in danger. 9. Sorry if it doesn't make sense , it's my first post. I think she did it as a bit of a “thank you” to Ron and Harry for coming to help and ultimately save her. yrmjd vhjzp ilc chnjcdl pkl xftjy pbch dpk mwyxp gxpcc